There’s nothing as tastey as an old fashion Buttermilk Pie! People tend to think it actually tastes like buttermilk but it doesn’t. It’s VERY sweet and easy!
INGREDIENTS:
- 1 refrigerated pie dough for single crust
- 1 cup sugar
- 2 1/2 tablespoons flour
- 2 eggs
- 1 3/4 cup buttermilk
DIRECTIONS:
Preheat oven to 350′. Pierce pie crust with a fork all over, and prebake for 5 minutes. Whisk remaining ingredients together and pour into pie crust; bake 50-60 minutes and till browned. You need to let it sit, cool, and settle before eating:) It’s hard to wait, I know!
TIP: You can add a touch of butter and/or vanilla for a richer pie.
MIXING TIME!
POUR INTO THE PIE SHELL TIME:)
And then eating time. Now I had every intention on taking a picture of the finished pie but my kiddos dug into before I could the picture of the whole pie!!! Here is a slice though;)
That’s a gorgeous slice.
I just love buttermilk pie. Mmmm
I LOVE it too! My oldest son could eat the whole thing in one sitting if we let him..lol.
Mmmmm… I love buttermilk pie! My grandma used to make this all the time!
Heather’s last blog post..Fight the Frump – Mood Boosters
My husband has been bugging me for months to make him a Buttermilk pie! He’s not from the South, and had never heard of it, so guess what I’m doing tomorrow??
Thanks for the recipe!
Melody’s last blog post..Taking a break
I would love to have a slice of your pie right now. My mother used to make buttermilk pies, and my grandmother, too. In fact, this was one of my mother’s very favorite pies. Oh, how I wish I could eat a piece of pie with her right now! I hope everyone appreciates the time they have with their parents, because when they’re gone… you miss them so much!
Charla’s last blog post..Four Foods on Friday #25 Questions
PS Lori, I read the Buttermilk Pie post before I read the one about your Dad. Your family will be in my prayers!
Charla’s last blog post..Four Foods on Friday #25 Questions
MMMMMMMMMMM I just love this pie!! MMMMMMMMMM
MMMMMMMMMM I just LOVE this Pie !! MMMMMMMMMM
I love the simplicity!
Oh my goodness…makes me want to go make my own right now! I love buttermilk pie!
the sustainable backyards last blog post..the omnivore
Yes I see the butter milk photos they look delicious!! I would love to try this recipe. It looks like a custard. I would never have thought that this recipe existed..
Very yummy looking! I love all the photos that show the steps.
buttermilk pie. Yes there are pictures.
The pie sounds wonderful and the pictures are a help for newbeees discovering cooking. Love new ideas that are simple! I’m a great cook wanna-be but with as much fun I’ve been having reading cook books and enjoying web sites, that’ll all be changing soon!!
Hello, I am new to your site and this pie looks fabulous. I have never tried a buttermilk pie, but I will be trying it soon.
I was wondering if this is a 8 or 9 inch pie? I want to make it for Thanksgiving!
To Amber… You asked if you should use a 8 or a 9 inch pie? I used a glass 9 inch pie pan. You will just love this pie and will be making it offten !!!
Kitchen Aid mixer spotted! kt